Top Mistakes Businesses Make When Choosing Property Insurance

Choosing the right property insurance for your business can feel like a daunting task. It’s essential to have the right coverage in place to protect your physical assets, but many business owners make critical mistakes when selecting their policy. These errors can result in inadequate coverage, unnecessary costs, or even gaps in protection that could harm your business in the event of a claim. In this article, we’ll walk through the top mistakes businesses often make when choosing property insurance, and how you can avoid them to ensure that your company is well-protected.

Top Mistakes Businesses Make When Choosing Property Insurance

1. Underestimating the Value of Their Property

One of the most common mistakes businesses make when choosing property insurance is underestimating the value of their property, including inventory, equipment, and buildings. If you insure your business for less than its true value, you may end up paying for repairs or replacements out of pocket in the event of a claim.

Why This is a Problem:

  • Underinsurance: If you don’t insure your property for its full replacement value, your policy may not pay out enough to cover the costs of rebuilding or replacing your assets.
  • Pro-Rata Reductions: Many insurance policies contain a “coinsurance clause,” which means if you’re underinsured, your payout may be reduced proportionally, leading to significant out-of-pocket expenses.

How to Avoid This Mistake:

  • Accurate Valuation: Regularly assess and update the value of your business assets. Be sure to include the cost of inventory, equipment, and even the property itself.
  • Get Professional Help: Consider consulting a property appraiser or insurance broker who can help accurately value your assets and ensure your coverage is sufficient.

2. Failing to Understand Policy Terms

Another common mistake is not fully understanding the terms and conditions of your policy. Property insurance policies often contain complex language, exclusions, and fine print that business owners may overlook or misinterpret.

Why This is a Problem:

  • Misleading Coverage: Without a clear understanding of your policy, you may believe you are covered for certain risks that are actually excluded, such as floods, earthquakes, or vandalism.
  • Surprise Costs: Business owners may also fail to grasp excess or deductibles, which can result in unexpected out-of-pocket expenses in the event of a claim.

How to Avoid This Mistake:

  • Read the Fine Print: Always review your policy in detail. If necessary, ask your insurance broker or provider to explain anything that seems unclear.
  • Clarify Exclusions: Make sure you understand what is excluded from your coverage. If there are risks that are important to your business (such as flooding or fire), you may need to add extra coverage or seek a policy that covers these risks.
  • Review Annually: Insurance needs can change as your business evolves. Review your policy at least once a year to ensure that it still provides the right level of coverage.

3. Choosing the Cheapest Option

While it’s tempting to go for the cheapest property insurance policy to cut costs, this can often be a costly mistake in the long run. Many budget policies offer minimal coverage or fail to meet your business’s needs, leaving you underinsured when you need it most.

Why This is a Problem:

  • Inadequate Coverage: Cheaper policies often exclude important coverage options, like business interruption insurance, or provide lower payout limits, meaning your business could suffer if something happens.
  • Higher Out-of-Pocket Costs: If you need to make a claim, you may find that the payout doesn’t cover the full cost of repairs, replacement, or legal fees.

How to Avoid This Mistake:

  • Balance Cost and Coverage: While it’s important to stay within your budget, the cheapest option might not provide the protection you need. Shop around for a policy that offers a good balance between cost and comprehensive coverage.
  • Prioritise Your Needs: Focus on the coverage that is most relevant to your business, such as fire, theft, or business interruption insurance, rather than simply going for the lowest premium.

4. Not Including Business Interruption Insurance

Many business owners focus solely on insuring their physical assets, such as buildings and equipment, without considering the impact of a potential interruption to their operations. Business interruption insurance helps cover lost income and operating expenses if your business has to close temporarily due to property damage or other covered events.

Why This is a Problem:

  • Lost Revenue: Without business interruption insurance, if your property is damaged or destroyed, you may face a long period of downtime without income. This can be particularly devastating for small businesses or startups that depend on continuous cash flow.
  • Ongoing Expenses: Even when your business is not operational, you still have ongoing expenses, such as rent, employee wages, and utility bills. Business interruption insurance helps cover these costs.

How to Avoid This Mistake:

  • Add Business Interruption Insurance: When purchasing property insurance, make sure it includes business interruption coverage. This way, you can ensure that your income stream is protected during the time it takes to repair or replace damaged assets.
  • Evaluate Your Risks: Consider how long it would take your business to get back on track after a disaster and tailor your coverage accordingly. Some policies allow you to customise your business interruption coverage to suit your specific needs.

5. Overlooking Liability Coverage

Another common mistake businesses make is assuming that property insurance alone will cover all potential risks. However, property insurance typically does not cover liability claims, such as injuries to customers, employees, or third parties that occur on your property.

Why This is a Problem:

  • Accidents and Injuries: If a customer slips and falls on your property or if an employee is injured while using your equipment, you could be held liable for their medical expenses, legal costs, and compensation claims.
  • Legal Costs: Lawsuits can be time-consuming and expensive, and if you don’t have liability coverage, the financial burden will fall directly on your business.

How to Avoid This Mistake:

  • Include Liability Insurance: Ensure that your property insurance policy includes general liability coverage. This protects your business in the event of accidents, injuries, or damage that occurs on your property.
  • Consider Additional Coverage: Depending on your industry, you may need additional types of liability coverage, such as product liability or professional indemnity insurance.

6. Not Updating Coverage as Your Business Grows

Startups and growing businesses often neglect to update their property insurance as they expand. As your business adds new equipment, hires more employees, or moves to larger premises, your insurance needs will evolve. If you don’t update your coverage, you may be left without sufficient protection.

Why This is a Problem:

  • Underinsurance: As your business grows, your assets, inventory, and operations become more valuable. If your coverage isn’t updated, you may find yourself underinsured in the event of a claim.
  • Exposing New Risks: Expanding your operations may introduce new risks that your current policy doesn’t cover, such as new property locations or additional business activities.

How to Avoid This Mistake:

  • Review Annually: Schedule regular reviews of your policy to make sure it reflects any changes in your business operations, assets, or location.
  • Notify Your Insurer: Inform your insurer whenever you acquire new property or make significant changes to your business. This ensures that your coverage remains up-to-date and relevant.

7. Ignoring the Importance of Reputation and Service

When choosing a property insurance provider, many businesses focus solely on price and coverage without considering the insurer’s reputation or customer service. A good insurer can make the claims process smoother, offer valuable advice, and provide ongoing support when you need it most.

Why This is a Problem:

  • Claims Hassles: If your insurer has poor customer service, you may face delays or complications when filing a claim. This can add unnecessary stress during an already challenging time.
  • Lack of Support: An insurer with a strong reputation will be more likely to provide proactive guidance and support when you need it, helping to avoid costly mistakes and ensuring your coverage meets your needs.

How to Avoid This Mistake:

  • Research Your Insurer: Take the time to research potential insurers and read reviews from other business owners. Look for an insurer that is known for excellent customer service and efficient claims handling.
  • Ask Questions: When speaking to an insurance agent, ask about their claims process and what kind of support they offer to business owners. This will give you a better idea of how they’ll respond if you ever need to make a claim.

Conclusion

Choosing the right property insurance for your business is essential to safeguarding your physical assets and ensuring the long-term success of your company. By avoiding these common mistakes, you can ensure that you have comprehensive coverage that meets your needs, protects your business from unexpected events, and provides the support necessary to keep your operations running smoothly. Take the time to research your options, understand your risks, and review your policy regularly to keep your business safe from financial setbacks.

Protect Your Business with the Right Coverage
Don’t leave your business exposed to unnecessary risks. Ensure you have the right commercial property insurance to safeguard your assets and operations.

Get a Quote Today

Explore More Articles

Commercial Property

Company

Stonewell Insurance Pty Ltd
ABN: 23 645 965 699
CAR: 128 5612

Authorised Representative of McLardy McShane Partners Pty Ltd
ABN: 14 064 465 309
AFS License No: 232987

The information provided is for general purposes only, and it is not a substitute for professional advice. You should always consider the PDS/Policy wording before making a decision. Coverage may differ based on specific clauses in individual policies. Refer to the FSG on our website or by requesting a copy for our services and remuneration details. 

Stonewell Insurance endorses the Insurance Brokers Code of Practice

© 2025 Commercial Property Cover | Stonewell Insurance PTY LTD | Designed by GCWebsites